Policy Press

Over-Efficiency in the Lower Criminal Courts

Understanding a Key Problem and How to Fix it

By Shaun Yates

Published

Jun 11, 2024

Page count

160 pages

ISBN

978-1529236392

Dimensions

203 x 127 mm

Imprint

Bristol University Press

Published

Jun 11, 2024

Page count

160 pages

ISBN

978-1529236408

Dimensions

203 x 127 mm

Imprint

Bristol University Press

Published

Jun 11, 2024

Page count

160 pages

ISBN

978-1529236408

Dimensions

203 x 127 mm

Imprint

Bristol University Press
Over-Efficiency in the Lower Criminal Courts

In our pursuit of efficiency in the lower criminal courts, have we lost sight of quality justice? Through the critical examination of original stenographic data, this book demonstrates how an English Magistrates' courthouse often pursued managerial efficiency to the detriment of social justice and procedural due process values.

Given that these courts process more than 95% of all criminal cases, this ‘over-efficiency’ problem has the capacity to cause significant social harm. Yates’s work concludes by providing socio-legal and criminological readers with ways to fix this over-efficiency problem. This accessible work is of value to policy makers and post-graduate students alike.

Shaun S. Yates is course leader for the Criminology and Law BA at London Metropolitan University and currently serves as the university’s Crime Challenge Champion Lead.

Chapter 1: Introduction

Chapter 2: The Modern History of Summary Justice Efficiency

Chapter 3: Speed-Focused Managerialism

Chapter 4: Standardised Defendant Processes

Chapter 5: Court Users’ Procedural Adversity

Chapter 6: Overcoming Over-Efficiency